Motherland Security
17 November, 2011

History of Georgia, as the past of many other smaller or bigger nations around the world is marked with ceaseless struggle for liberty and independence. Even the United States of America, as big and powerful as it is today, had in its own time shed huge amount of tears and blood to acquire the independence and to enjoy the liberty it has heroically fought for throughout centuries. 

In America, the notions of liberty, rights and equality were elevated to the rank of the most precious national values. Those values have always superseded the necessity of physical safety or economic security. But the world is changing fast, and certain bothering questions are popping up inadvertently: What if entertaining personal freedoms and administering universal liberty of an individual threaten national safety and curb the citizens’ security in the country? What if society feels and behaves so freely that its protection from wickedness becomes practically impossible for the state? What if some day democracy is rendered powerless – due to excessive freedom – to provide for a peaceful and qualitative life? Shall we in this case be faced with an option like – freedom or safety? And if we actually are, what are we going to do? Shall we opt for freedom or for safety? If we believe Benjamin Franklin, one of the Founding Fathers of America, preference should be given to freedom –‘Those who give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.’ These are the words which were written in stone up until now. Should we faithfully continue believing in the quarter-of-a-millennium wisdom, a crystal-clear Western political and philosophical value? I doubt it – let the soul of the great American forgive my temerity to contradict the genius. Ideally, we need to enjoy all those values fully and simultaneously – liberty, safety, rights, equality, consent, democracy, sense of eternal security, defeat of the evil and celebration of the good. If this is possible of course without any substantiated misgivings about our current life, fraught with scary occurrences and our future, loaded with raw sense of uncertainty. Personally, I prefer for my beloved Georgia all-rounded safety – economic, territorial, political, social, psychological, medical and ideological – even if the loss of individual freedoms become inevitable when the situation in the country is dictating so. If life is at stake and measures are to be taken for survival purposes, I would easily give up on personal liberty and broad democracy. The issue is being just as acute and incisive in the United States. What do we need more – liberty or safety when push comes to shove, when having both is no longer possible? I am not trying to justify any restriction of human rights. I know exactly what they mean. I am just giving a regular heads-up in case we are compelled to make the difficult choice. There is nothing wrong with getting ready for proper handling of a problem if the problem occurs, is there? And a problem might occur anytime!

Other Stories
Can Georgia Handle This?
We are used to handling minor social rifts as well as major political chasms in Georgia, but this does not mean that we are handling them right.
Abortive Controversy
Using the word ‘abortion’ has always been considered an indecorous turn of the tongue in this culture: good moms and dads would feel uncomfortable, for instance, if their well-bread kids used this ‘impolite’ word publicly; a prim and prudish teacher would tell off a certain loutish student provided the word was used freely when at school; a lady of self-respect would goggle her eyes in indignation at an uncouth admirer if the unfortunate guy blurted out that ‘swearword’ incidentally. Why? Was there something so terribly unpleasant about the word? Could be, but no longer is this the case in Georgia! This recent Easter, Georgia started not only using the word publicly and unreservedly, but has embarked on discussing the abortion extensively.
Blunder at Sotheby’s
Lado Gudiashvili is the 20th century eminent Georgian painter. He is this Nation’s pride and wealth, whose outstanding legacy is lovingly praised by the entire contemporary Georgia and treasured in our hearts and minds forever.
Ketchup Macnecdote
All my friends and relatives know that McDonald’s is not my favorite place to have my appetite quenched at because fast food in general is not what I would die for.
Educational Quandary?
Level of education as such, including its content and quality, always leaves a lot to desire whenever and wherever in the world this education is taking place. Education is never enough and it is never satisfactory, never completely up to the point and never fully compatible with the requirements of time.
Cooperatives – where are they?
Most of the tools for making money have already been invented by man. Probably! Well, some of these tools come and go, but some are so strong and proven that they persistently stay in place almost for good. Cooperatives make exactly this kind of an instrument for generating income. Using the now obsolescent Soviet type of vocabulary, it was called CEKAVSHIRI in the Georgian language, meaning Central Union of Consumer Cooperatives.
‘Magna Carta’
The Magna Carta of England of 1215 proclaimed certain liberties, and emphasized that the king could no longer rule arbitrarily.
In neutral venues?
The building looks gorgeous both inside and out, and impresses beyond any doubt. On the television at least! The transparent greenish glass coating outside and the snow-white parliamentary scenery inside makes this ultra-modern architectural complex a real eye-catcher.
Star Mania
I remember like yesterday my 1990 stint in Hollywood, meant to create the so called ‘Nug-Story’ about the Hollywood Walk of Fame for WXIA TV-Atlanta, for which I had worked for several years as part of Georgia-to-Georgia journalistic exchange right at the start of that ill-famed Perestroika (reconstruction) in the Soviet Union.
Handling Georgia Right
Questions, questions, questions! Hundreds of questions! Unanswered, incorrectly posed, not-yet-asked ones! Smart, up-to-the-point, reasonable ones! Thick, irrational, ludicrous ones! Questions all the way! Questions all the time!
Nomenclature
Nomenclature was a big word in the country of soviets. It sounded like God’s payroll, on which the names of only the strongest and the fittest of the soviet land were destined to figure. Once you got on it you would own some dream sinecure for the rest of your life unless you fell out of priceless favor of soviet powers that be.
Georgian Women’s Rule
I am not a feminist. I have never been one. Neither am I a macho-oriented dude. I have never wanted to be. I am a regular practitioner of reason and fairness. And this article would never have seen the light had I had a funny propensity to be any of those species.
Demographically Maladjusted
The recent UN survey is confirming that there is a heartbreaking tendency of population shrinkage in Georgia, purportedly meaning that we might not be around physically in a couple of centuries, maybe even earlier. Using the most relevant sample of juxtaposition, the number of people living in the neighboring Azerbaijan and Armenia is happily and intensively growing.
Political Wrestlers
I love American wrestling but most of it happens to be faked, although sometimes the impression is that those famous big men in America are fighting in earnest. The picture in our local political life is totally different.
Starting from Scratch
We all know very well that starting something from scratch is a huge pain in the neck. This is equal to starting that something right from point zero. This practically means that there is nothing in your hands to start with, to rely on, to play with and to develop – just an empty place to build the cherished ‘something’ on.
GJ Editor's comment
23 May, 2013
We are used to handling minor social rifts as well as major political chasms in Georgia, but this does not mean that we are handling them right.
Also on the Web
Two church representatives face allegations by the Interior Ministry Tbilisi Main Section for their actions during the May 17 protest against the planned demonstration for marking the International Day Against Homophobia and Transphobia on Rustaveli Avenue in Tbilisi.
Tako Salakaia, wife of the detained former Prime Minister Vano Merabishvili said the family of the former minister as well as his friends and relatives were behind Merabishvili and would “fight until the end”.
A Georgian Defense Ministry delegation led by Minister Alasania is visiting Baltic states on an official visit.
A man has died in a suspected terror attack in London sparking a national security alert.
The victim was hacked to death by two assailants who were then shot by police.
Patriarch of Georgia Ilia II said the “insulting” behavior of the church representatives during their May 17 protest against the planned demonstration for marking the International Day Against Homophobia and Transphobia was “disappointing”
Former Prime Minister Vano Merabishvili and Kakheti Region Governor Zurab Tchiaberashvili's appearance in court was greeted with applause by their supporters attending the case hearing on May 22.
Tako Salakaia, wife of the detained former Prime Minister Vano Merabishvili, returned to Georgia on May 23.
Kutaisi City Court assigned preliminary detention as preventive measure for Former Prime Minister Vano Merabishvili but accepted 20 thousand Lari as bail for Kakheti Region Governor Zurab Tchiaberashvili on May 22.
Image Center modeling agency is receiving applications for the Miss Georgia 2013 contest, Manager Ia Kitsmarishvili announced at a press conference on May 22.
A row has erupted between Russia and Azerbaijan over the Eurovision song contest, with the Russian foreign minister accusing the Azerbaijanis of vote-rigging.
GEL Exchange
GBP
1
GBP
2.4692
RUB
100
RUB
5.2389
TRY
1
TRY
0.8882
EUR
1
EUR
2.1153
USD
1
USD
1.6360